The Part I Left Out

Hello, Friends. This is the fourth time I've written to you this month, and the last. The three before it sat in hard places and didn't pretend otherwise. This one ends somewhere different. We start here.

There were two performances. Our chorus sang on a Friday night and again the Saturday evening that followed — the same program both nights, or nearly. Between them, one thing changed. Not the music. The thing I said in the middle of it.

Somewhere in the second half of our concerts, I get up and say a few words. It isn't required of me; I do it because I can't help reaching for the chance — to connect what we're singing that night to why this chorus exists at all. I'd written that night's message earlier in the same week, fast, close to whatever I was feeling. On Friday I stood up in the middle of the second half and delivered it the way I'd written it. On Saturday I stood in the same place and delivered something else, and I told the room why I had. What happened between those two nights is the closest thing I have to a reason for hope — and it didn't come from me. It came to me, handed over by someone in the chorus who saw what I'd missed and decided to tell me.

I've spent this month writing about the cost of being unseen. I want to end it on the opposite: what it is to be seen by someone, and corrected, and made better for it.

A few weeks before those performances, we lost one of our own.

He and I had joined the chorus the same season, years earlier. The first rehearsal, when you don't know where to sit or who anyone is, I sat down next to him — or he next to me; I've lost track of which, and it doesn't matter, because after that we were simply the two who'd started together. He was one of those people a room reorganizes itself around. When he came through the door at rehearsal, something lifted; you could watch it happen on people's faces. He was funny in the way that makes other people braver, and warm in a way that asked nothing back.

He died unexpectedly, and far earlier than anyone would have been prepared for.

I'm not going to try to give him to you whole here — I couldn't, and it isn't what this essay is for. But I'll tell you the thing I keep closest. A chorus like ours is full of people who arrived because they needed somewhere to belong, and for a lot of us, the chorus is not a hobby; it is the family we assembled when the first one couldn't hold us, or wouldn't. He was one of those people. We were, in the realest sense the word has, his. And we were about to stand on a stage and sing without him for the first time.

That was where I was the week I sat down to write what I'd say.

I won't reproduce what I said that Friday. But I can tell you what it was made of.

It was made of him, first — the empty space in the risers where he should have been standing. And it was made of the year we were singing into. That spring, statehouses across the country were moving hundreds of bills aimed at people like us: who we could be in public, which bathrooms, which books, which children, which care. You could not keep count of them, and the not-being-able-to-keep-count was itself the point — the volume was the message. I stood up in the middle of the second half and I named all of it. The friend we'd lost. The country that seemed, that season, to be deciding out loud how much of us it would tolerate. I meant every word. I thought the moment demanded that someone say the true and heavy thing, and so I did.

We were singing "Singing for Our Lives" that night — the old movement hymn, the one people have sung at vigils and on courthouse steps for fifty years, holding hands in the dark. It is a song you reach for when you are afraid and refuse to be silent anyway. That Friday, that is exactly how I framed it, and exactly how we sang it: as defiance. As something you do because the alternative is to disappear. We sang it like people refusing to be moved.

And it was true. None of what I said was wrong. I want to be clear about that before I tell you what happened next, because the easy version of this story would make my Friday self a fool, and I wasn't one. I had lost my friend. I was watching my country argue about whether people like me should be able to live in it without interference, and I was standing in front of people I loved trying to say something honest about the dark. If you'd been in that with me, you'd have written what I wrote.

And it reached people. I know because they told me — audience members and singers both, finding me afterward to say they were grateful I'd said it, that they'd needed someone to name the year out loud. The heaviness had been true to them too. Nobody left that night thinking I'd misjudged the room.

Which is what made the next part so easy to have missed.

The message came the next day. I was home, and I read it on my laptop, and I read it more than once.

It was from a member of the chorus. They use they and them, and I want to get that right, because they'd just done something genuinely generous for me. They'd been there Friday, standing on the risers behind me as I spoke — they'd heard every word from a few feet away. And what they wrote — I'm giving you the substance of it, not the exact words, because I didn't think to save them and I wish I had — was that they didn't disagree with any of it. The grief was real. The danger was real. But they wanted me to know that the thing I'd stood up and named was not the whole of what we were. Being queer, they said, was not mostly about the dark. We had something most people never got to have. We built family out of strangers. We made rooms where people who'd been turned away their whole lives could finally walk in and be held. We knew how to make light for each other — and we did it, over and over, precisely because we knew what its absence felt like. That, they wanted me to remember, was at least as true as anything I'd said.

They weren't telling me I was wrong. That's what I keep coming back to. They weren't correcting an error — Friday hadn't been an error. They were standing inside a room that had just agreed with me about the dark, and they were choosing, gently, to say: and also this. To add the part I'd left out — not because I'd failed to see it, but because someone had to carry it back into the light, and they'd decided it would be them.

I read it again. What I felt was not embarrassment. It was something closer to relief — the specific relief of being handed back a piece of the truth you'd been too deep in to reach. They were doing for me, in a message on an ordinary afternoon, the exact thing they were describing. They were making light for someone who'd lost sight of it. They were proving their own point on me.

The Saturday performance was that evening.

I rewrote the message that afternoon — not all of it, but the end of it, the part that decides what lingers after the lights come up. And when I stood up in the middle of the second half that night, I told them the truth: that someone in this chorus had seen me clearly, kindly, after Friday, and reminded me of something I'd left out. That the grief was real and I wasn't taking it back. But that grief was never the whole of us, and I'd been wrong to let it stand alone. We were also the people in this room. We were the family some of us had to go out and build. We were, even now, even in this year, a people who knew how to make light for each other — because we were the ones who'd gone looking for it in the dark and learned the way.

And then we sang "Singing for Our Lives" again.

The same song. The same notes, the same hands, the same room. But it was not the same song, because I was not hearing it the same way. Friday we had sung it as defiance — as people refusing to vanish. Saturday we sang it as what it had always also been, underneath the defiance: a love song. People who had found each other, singing about the fact of having found each other. The defiance was still in there. It just wasn't alone in there anymore. Nobody in the audience knew the difference. I knew it in my whole body.

That is the gift I was given, between two nights, by someone who didn't have to give it. They could have sat with their disagreement and let it pass. Friday had gone fine; no one was asking them to fix it. They reached out anyway, and they handed me back a piece of the truth, and they trusted me to be the kind of person who could take it. I have led for a long time. I know how rare it is to be handed something like that — and how much rarer it is to actually receive it instead of defending the thing you already wrote.

So I'll leave you where they left me.

Somewhere in your life there is a person who has done this for you — who saw you standing too long in the dark and reached over, quietly, to turn part of the light back on. Maybe they corrected you. Maybe they just sat beside you on the first day, when you didn't know where to sit. You probably never told them what it did. We almost never do. The people who make light for us are so used to making it that they assume it goes unnoticed, and so we let it. Go tell them. It will take you a sentence, and it will mean more than you think.

And then do the harder thing, which is to believe what they were trying to tell you. The dark is real — I have never once pretended otherwise, least of all this month. But it was never the larger thing. The larger thing, if you will let yourself see it, is the staggering amount of light that ordinary people make for each other every day, mostly unthanked, mostly unseen — the doors held open, the seats saved, the strangers turned into family, the corrections offered in love. It is everywhere. It outweighs the dark by orders of magnitude. We just have a harder time seeing light than dark, because the dark demands to be looked at and the light waits to be noticed. This month I let myself get lost in what demands. I want to end it by pointing at what waits.

That is what they gave me, between two nights: not a denial of the dark, but my eyes back. And the thing about your eyes is that once they're open, the light was always already there — in your life, in your people, in the rooms you walk through without registering how much care is holding them up. You don't have to manufacture it. You only have to stop letting the dark be the only thing you see.

There is so much more light than dark. There always was. Someone may have to remind you — and then, someday, you get to be the one who reminds someone else.

"We knew how to make light for each other, because we were the ones who went looking for it in the dark." — MB

The Human Leader Project is a weekly essay on the small, often invisible ways we hold power over one another's experience. If it's the kind of thing you want to keep finding in your inbox, you can subscribe at www.humanleaderproject.com.

On July 16th at 1PM ET, beehiiv is going live with a look at the future of publishing, audience growth, and digital business.

What started as a newsletter platform has evolved into something much bigger: a place where creators and brands can grow, monetize, and own their audiences without stitching together half the internet to make it work.

The next chapter starts live at the Summer Release Event. 

Join us to see what’s coming next.

RSVP now.